Thursday, January 30, 2014

Blog Post # 3 / Role of the Teacher

 
Question I will be Exploring: To what extent should teachers provide their students with direct answers? Is it better for students to find the answer themselves through active experimentation and exploration?
Similarly, should a teacher provide students with a rigid set of procedures to complete a project or let the students develop their own path and methods?
 
     I formed this question based on chapter four "Building Bridges" from Bill Ayers' To Teach, the Journey in Comics. Based on my reading and personal experience, I believe that teachers should not give students direct answers, but rather let the students discover the answers themselves. What the teacher should do, however, is use a sort of Socratic Method to ask the students questions that will prompt them to think critically. Ayers promotes this concept on pages 49-50 when the students are talking about building a bridge for their pet turtle. Instead of telling the students how to build the bridge, the teacher asks the students critical questions to consider, such as how they will make the bridge safe for the turtle. As the teacher says, "I'll lay the first plank [of the bridge] and you can take it from there" (57). A teacher can provide students with a start, a foundation of knowledge, but then he should allow them to explore and form their own conclusions.
     Even in my own experience as a student, I have found that I learn material better when I discover the answer myself.  For example, I once had a math teacher that would always give me the answer if I didn't know how to solve the problem. This practice was actually detrimental to me because I never learned the necessary method.  Instead, if that teacher had helped me to work through the method and find the answer on my own, I would have had a richer understanding of the material.
      This concept of students finding their own answers also applies to our education class. For example, we were allowed to create skits and describe how we interpreted the Bill Ayers chapters.
 
P.S. Note to Dr. Shutkin: This blog reminded me of a great teacher I had at John Carroll, Dr. Macaskill. He started off our first class last semester by saying "I'm not here to teach you." He then proceeded to give his view of the role of the teacher. I would like to tell you about what he said and his teaching methods some time if you are interested. He made a great impact on me and my decision to take this education class.  
 
 


Monday, January 27, 2014

Blog Post #2 Mall Observation

My chart of observations:

 
Description: 
  *People are sharing food. A young boy, around three years old, gives his mother a bite of his
    pizza. The boy has dark brown, almond shaped eyes and dark brown hair. The mother smiles
    when she receives the bite of pizza.
 
Interpretation:
   * The mother is happy to see her son and to see that he is sharing. 
 
Description:
 *The mother, who has long black hair around shoulder length, speaks to an older woman with a
   dark brown bob. The older woman is probably in her fifties or sixties. They speak a 
   language other than English. The two women smile warmly at each other. The older woman hands 
   a small amount of money to the younger woman.  
 
Interpretation:
  *Perhaps the two women know each other. They may even possibly be related. They could be
    mother and daughter.
 
Description:
   *The older woman gives the younger woman a high five and they speak excitedly.
 
Description:
   * There are advertisements all throughout the food court. One large advertisement hanging on a
       wall is for a car dealership. There are also advertisements above the various restaurants
        displaying the food being sold. All of the advertisements are illuminated.
 
Interpretation: 
    *The mall is a good place to target consumers. The mall receives a lot of traffic so the
       advertisements are sure to be seen. Also, since the mall is full of people buying products,
       it can be assumed that these people would be interested in buying other goods in the future. 
       The signs are illuminated because the light helps attract the eye of the passerby.
 
Description:
    * There is a mix of natural and artificial light in the food court. Skylights help to keep the area
        bright. There is music playing in the background. Music, however, is not the only sound. There
        is a cacophony of noises including people talking, spatulas scraping against grills, and in the
        distance there is the sound of someone shaking a plastic bag.
 
Description: 
     * A young boy is sitting at the table to the left of me. He has dark hair and dark eyes. He is
         probably about four years old. He is wearing a cream colored sweater with a picture of a dog
         on it. He yells an unintelligible sound very loudly and his father gently scolds him. The boy
         procceds to hold the food he is eating up to his nose (presumably to smell it). Next, the boy
         begins to walk around as he eats and even gets up to look under the table.
 
Interpretation:
        * The boy seems to be very curious about his environment. He seems to be completely
           occupied by his wonder.
 
Description
        * An elderly man with circular glasses sits alone at a table near me. He has grey hair but it is
            very thin and wispy. He flips through a long, printed, formal document. The document has 
            text and graphs. He compares the document he is reading to a notepad he has been writing on.
             He looks back and forth from document to document multiple times. During this process, he
             never once looks up from his work. Finally, he stops looking from document to document,
             looks up and smiles.
 
Interpretation:
          *The man seems to be very focused on his work. Perhaps when he looks up and smiles he has
             found an important connection.
 
Description:
           * Many families are gathered in the food court. They share tables, food, and conversation.
 
Interpretation:
            * Shopping and especially eating are bonding experiences.
 
Description:
            * Two young girls, probably in elementary school, wear thick coats, hats, and other winter
                gear. They have bright beads in their hair. They approach us and ask us to support their
                swim team by buying a chocolate bar. The girls speak very quietly and keep their eyes
                down.
 
Interpretation:
            * The girls seem to be nervous and shy. Perhaps they are not used to approaching and 
                talking to strangers. They may be nervous because they are speaking to people 
                 who they do not know and who are much older.
        
                                          Reflection
     I completed this assignment with Josh DeJesus. When we compared our notes, we discovered that we interpreted what we saw very differently due to our different backgrounds and mental filters. For example, when describing people, I normally focused on physical attributes such as hair and eye color. Josh, on the other hand, often described race. Although I noticed race, I consciously chose not to describe it. I attended a public school that was homogenously white and Christian. Race for me, therefore, tends to be a taboo subject. I am in no way racist. Perhaps I am just somewhat uncomfortable talking about race.  Josh grew up in a very racially diverse school and was, therefore, more comfortable with the topic.
     Another major difference between our descriptions was that mine tended to be more detailed and descriptive whereas Josh's were more general. My tendency toward description probably stems from my love of literature and writing poems. I also seemed to focus more on the mix of contrasting noises that filled the room. I was much attuned to the various sounds because I am passionate about music.
     A final major difference between our descriptions was that I concentrated on many of the advertisements I saw around me. I described the type of advertisements and how they were illuminated to attract people's eye. I noticed the advertisements not because of something from my background, but rather because of something affecting me presently. This semester I am taking a Consumer Politics and Culture Class, in which we often discuss the nature of advertising.
    


This is a funny comic about perspective that I can relate to!
 

Tuesday, January 14, 2014

    
Personal Information
My real name is Katherine, but I prefer to be called Katie.  I am from Chesterland, Ohio. I would like to teach at either the high school or collegiate level. I would love to teach English, specifically literature. Ever since a young age, I have had a passion for reading and writing. I love reading novels and considering the rhetoric strategies of the author. A second subject I would possibly like to teach is speech/communications. In terms of my interests, I really enjoy listening to blues and rock music. I also play the guitar. A unique fact about me is that I am only 4 ft. 10 in. tall, which technically makes me a legal midget.
This is my favorite guitar.  

Learning Style and More
In order to take intellectual and creative risks in the classroom, I need to get to know my peers better. The better I know my peers, the more comfortable I feel sharing ideas. I think these blogs and the ability to explore other students' blogs is a great way to meet my need.

I perceive myself as a very motivated and hardworking student. I always come prepared to class and complete all reading assignments, even if I will not be tested on the material.
I work to contribute to class discussions and will often volunteer an answer at times when others are unwilling. I almost always take notes over readings, even if it is not required.  I learn best from reading the material (visual learning) and from actively doings things (tactile learning).  I have also noticed that I learn best in classes that do not follow the same exact routine every day and classes that are discussion based. If I do not understand something, the first thing I do is try to look at it from a different angle or use a different method to understand it. A weakness I have as a student is that I often over-study or focus on minor details.

Education Past and Present
A formative memory from my experience as a student was when one of my teachers went out of his way to help me succeed. I had been struggling with severe test anxiety in his class. He pulled me aside one day after class and talked to me about different strategies I could use to combat my anxiety. His strategies and some follow up discussions helped me to get over my fear. He made a huge positive impact on my life. This experience really is what pushed me toward the field of education. I wanted to be able to help students just as my teacher had helped me.

A significant issue facing the field of education right now is job outlook. I have heard from many people I know that they are struggling to find a job in education. This fact frightens me and tends to sway me away from the field. A second significant issue is the general moral of the people in the field. Many teachers seem to be unhappy in their profession and unhappy with the state education is in. My father has been teacher for many years and he strongly encouraged me to stay away from pursuing education. He said that he and other teachers from other school districts are facing harder and unfair state standards and frozen or decreasing pay.

About Dr. Shutkin
What factors caused you to decide to pursue a career in education?

Did you ever have another profession besides being a teacher?